North Star Metrics for AI Products Beyond Accuracy
When I ask teams how they measure success in their AI product, most immediately say “accuracy.” It is a natural instinct. If the model is accurate, the product must be working, right?
Not exactly. Accuracy is important, but it is not enough. AI products need a North Star metric that captures real user value and business outcomes, not just technical performance.
What is a North Star Metric
A North Star metric is the single measure that best reflects the value your product delivers to users. It is not about how clever the model is. It is about whether people are actually better off because of it.
Why Accuracy Falls Short
A writing assistant could generate text with 95 percent accuracy, but if users do not trust it or spend more time fixing the output than writing from scratch, the product fails. Accuracy tells you the model is functioning. It does not tell you the product is succeeding.
Examples of North Star Metrics in AI
AI support chatbot: percentage of tickets resolved end-to-end without human escalation.
Recommendation engine: uplift in conversions or time spent engaging with content over last X days.
AI coding assistant: percentage of code suggestions accepted and used by developers or increased productivity.
AI tutor: percentage of students reaching learning milestones faster.
These North Stars tie model performance directly to user value.
Supporting Metrics Still Matter
Accuracy, latency, recall, and precision are not irrelevant. They are supporting metrics that explain why your North Star moves. But they cannot replace it. Think of the North Star as the compass and supporting metrics as the instruments on the dashboard.
The Role of the PM
Defining the North Star is not a technical exercise. It is a product exercise. The PM’s job is to make sure the chosen metric reflects value that users care about and outcomes the business depends on.
Final Thought
AI products succeed not when the model hits a benchmark but when users adopt, trust, and keep coming back. A North Star metric forces you to focus on that bigger picture. Accuracy is a milestone. Value is the destination.
💡 This post is part of my ongoing series on AI Product Management.
If you enjoyed it, consider subscribing to get the next article straight in your inbox.
Feel free to share it with your team or anyone exploring how AI is reshaping product management.